Welcome Guest Login Apartments, Events, Restaurants, UWS Directory, Shiurs, Mincha , Newsletter

                              Home     Apartments     Articles       Photos      Videos           Blog      Events       Shiurs      

Related Articles

Published on: 12-31-2014

2013 Year End Movie Review
Published on: 12-31-2013

Sundance Movie Review: "We Are What We Are"
Published on: 01-29-2013

Sundace Movie Review: Escape From Tomorrow
Published on: 01-28-2013

Sundance Movie Review: Concussion
Published on: 01-28-2013

Sundance Movie Review: FRUITVALE
Published on: 01-26-2013

Sundace Movie Review: BLACKFISH
Published on: 01-26-2013

Sundance Movie Review: "Touchy Feely"
Published on: 01-23-2013

Sundance Movie Review: The Necessary Death of Charlie Countryman,
Published on: 01-23-2013

Sundance Movie Review: "Blue Caprice"
Published on: 01-22-2013


Next Article>>  << Previous Article
Category: Movies that Bang

Eastern Promises (2007)

by Jordan Hiller Posted: 12-06-2007(Viewed 4927 times)

In David Cronenberg's first prime (1986-1991), he would use somber, bug-eyed, off kilter actors like Jeff Goldblum and Peter Weller to tell bugged out, off kilter, somber tales - tragedies predominantly. In his second prime (which humbly began with 2002's Spider and gained steam with 2005's A History of Violence) he began using soft featured, handsome Hollywood actors (like Ralph Fiennes and Viggo Mortensen). Has Cronenberg gone mainstream?

Not really, though I believe he is enjoying the attention.

His last two films, both starring Mortensen, revolve around men skilled in doling out physical pain and death, who live deeply embedded within a lie. Almost to the point of completely vanishing.

Both films involve crime families and the ties that bind. Eastern Promises is an expose of the Russian mafia operating with reckless abandon in contemporary London. While Mortensen, as Nikolai, and Naomi Watts as a doctor who gets dragged in by happenstance (yet, how do you like that, her father was Russian), are the central characters, the mafia and its daunting, cold, heartless, presence is the central artery. And we are not dealing with just any mafia. Though the elements of murder, respect, tradition, and organized crime under the guise of upstanding business remain constant within the genre identified with Coppola and Scorsese, this is the RUSSIAN mob (likely Jewish as Mortensen at one point make a l'chayim). The accents are thick, the vendettas unique, the codes (such as storytelling tattoos) are culture specific. It almost feels like a dramatization of different dreamed up Russian mob scenarios. There seems to be no point to it all other that to craft an unsettling motion picture with some grisly close ups of throats being slit.

A testament to the directionlessness of the film is the wasted talents of Naomi Watts. Here is a woman capable of accomplishing anything on screen and yet she is required to do nothing other than appear mildly concerned. Her character delivers the baby of a young girl exported in from Kiev for prostitution purposes and is killed after becoming pregnant with an important child.

Eastern Promises is diverting, but it hardly lives up to its pedigree. Mortensen is sleepwalking through a convoluted plot and not because he isn't trying, but because the character, as written, is bland and emotionless.

However, his resume can forever note that in Eastern Promises the actor evaded two murderous thugs in a bathhouse and viciously turned the tables on them - while naked. The only stand out performance is turned in by Vincent Cassel as ambivalent, insecure mafia prince, Kirill, who seethes self-disgust and mayhem.

For whatever reason, Cronenberg only hints of the homosexual relationship between Nikolai and Kirill. Also only hinted at is Nikolai's motivations and an explanation for the curious trajectory of his career. At first he is a mere "driver" and lackey of Kirill. The mafia boss, played with the usual delicate compassion masking menace by Armin Mueller-Stahl, barely recognizes Nikolai's existence. Days later Nikolai has risen through the ranks, surpassed Kirill as the favorite son, and is looking to take over the family…but there is a twist (and not a believable or original one – just a convenient one).

And let us not forget there is a baby to save, giving Watts something to appear concerned about. I'm all for shades of grey and ambiguity, but Eastern Promises crosses the line - almost arrogantly - into the realm of inconsistency and fantasy. Cronenberg has not lost his touch as a filmmaker and as a director willing to push the boundaries of audience comfort. With the right script he is an adept visual artist, but Eastern Promises, like a KGB sniper sloshed on Vodka, misses the mark.

POST A REPLY    Print    Refer to Friend

Next Article >> << Previous Article

Bangin' Reader Comments:

From: Alex, Teaneck, NJ
Date: 04-27-2008
Rating: 8
Comments: I pretty much agree with the comments of the critic.  I would go even further and say the film is not even worth recommending.  The article is actually more daring than the movie is.  The writer is bold enough not to follow the crowd blinded by the successful earlier film "A History of Violence".  There is no new ground broken in this film.  There is nothing special about the bath house fight scene other than that Mortensen is naked.  The story is weak, has no real ending, wastes characters- in short, it tries to get by on mood and acting.  And I agree that the only performance that stands out is that of Vincent Cassell, who is better than his part.

Average Rating:8 out of 10

About us    Advertise with us    Post Something Funny! Contact us    Get RSS Feeds
Kosher Top Tens | Apartments/Classifieds that bang | Movies that bang | The bangitout blog | Videos that bang | Photos that bang | Events that bang | Kosher Restaurants Map | Shiur/Classes Map | Caption Contest | Bangitout Press |
© bangitout.com 2000-2009.    All Rights Reserved